General Glucosamine Information
|
Glucosamine has been studied for well over 40 years in
humans1 and it has been used in prized
thoroughbred horses, cats, dogs and even exotic animals. When it comes to
safety, some clinical studies have reported more side effects in a sugar
pilled placebo than with Glucosamine! Remember, Glucosamine is found
naturally in the body and is a natural nutraceutical product. According to
the Institute of Medicine and National Academies, “in Europe in
approximately 1960, physicians introduced the use of glucosamine sulfate
as an injectable therapeutic agent in the treatment of
osteoarthritis2.”
Hundreds of thousands of people have used Glucosamine,
and many have found it extremely effective to not only effectively ease
their arthritis pain but to also to provide them with far more than just
long lasting pain relief. Glucosamine has been shown in clinical studies
to regrow cartilage3, slow the progression
of arthritis, and possibly even modify the disease itself with almost no
side effects.
The most common reaction when you have mild pain or a
headache or the like is to turn to a bottle of your favorite over the
counter medication, such as aspirin or ibuprofen. The New England Journal
of Medicine reports that “anti-inflammatory drugs (prescription and
over-the-counter, which include Advil®, Motrin®, Aleve®, Ordus®, Aspirin,
and over 20 others) alone cause over 16,500 deaths and over 103,000
hospitalizations per year in the US”, according to a review article
published in the New England Journal of Medicine4 Everything from stomach bleeding to intestinal
damage to liver failure can result from the long term use and interactions
with what are known as NSAIDS, or Non-Steroidal Anti-Inflammatory Drugs.
Fortunately, Glucosamine not only safely and effectively eases the pain of
arthritis while working to do something that NSAIDS cannot do – rebuild
cartilage. Don’t just treat the symptoms and cover up the pain, get more
at the root of the problem and don’t neglect your body in an attempt to
just cover the pain.
In the U.S., baby boomers (who started turning 50 in
1996) are doing so at a rate of 300,000 per month5. Even if you have not reached 50 yet, it is
important to take steps now to slow down the effects of arthritis.
Arthritis has no cure and it will not get better on its own, but a daily
regimen of Glucosamine can help to keep your joints strong and maintain
your cartilage for years to come.
Also, if you are taking or plan to begin taking
Glucosamine for your arthritis, then you need to check the bottle. If you
see (Glucosamine Sulfate * KCl) or (Glucosamine Sulfate * NaCl) or
Glucosamine Sulfate as a Salt, then you should be aware that up to 30% or
more6 of the Glucosamine is being bound up
in salts. But the manufacturers can legally say that they are giving you
whatever dosage is listed on the bottle but the active, bioavailabile
amount of actual Glucosamine is going to be much smaller than the reported
dosage because it has to be carried by the salts. Generally you will only
find these deceptive (but unfortunately legal) practices in the very cheap
glucosamine products, but you should be aware that you get what you pay
for, and when it comes to important things like your body, one shouldn’t
skimp. Your car can break down and you can fix it if you had to, but you
only get one body. |
At the right dosages (1,500 mg per day), glucosamine has been shown
for decades to be effective at easing the pain of arthritis and joint pain as
well as going further to help rebuild cartilage - something traditional NSAID
pain relievers are unable to do. Indeed, the research is there, scores and
scores of placebo controlled double blind studies report these same facts over
and over. These studies used a standardized amount of glucosamine – something
that not all manufacturers actually provide.
Because so few manufacturers actually line their products up against the
competition, we have assembled a list of popular commercially available products
out there to review and have included, for each product, the following items:
(Read below for a full product review).
|
Product Name |
|
|
Glucosamine Dosage Amount: |
1,500 mg is the suggested dose |
|
Price (Per Dose): |
Should be between $.85 and $1.20 a dose |
|
Price (Per Month): |
Should be between $30 and $50 a month |
|
Dosage Amount Supplied: |
Should last a full month or more |
|
Glucosamine Form: |
Ideally contain both HCL and Sulfate |
|
Ingredient Purity: |
Should be Superior Quality |
|
Physical Form: |
Should be Liquid |
|
Synergistic Factors: |
As long as cost is reasonable, should contain as many as
possible |
|
Shipping Cost: |
Ideally it should be free or under
$3.50 |
As many of you have heard, there have been problems with several
nutraceutical manufactures out there, for some of the less honest ones have been
selling products that simply do not contain what they claim to contain. Many
others use tricks like giving you 60 pills and then requiring you to take 4 a
day, so you really think you are getting a 60 day supply when in reality you are
only getting a 15 day supply. Many places wait to charge you shipping until
after you have spent several minutes typing in all of your ordering information,
thinking what is another 5 or 6 bucks once you have gotten that far. Fortunately
there are good, honest companies out there. You just have to take the time to
review the hundreds of generic and brand name glucosamine products out there. We
have done the work for you and scientifically reviewed some of the more popular
products below.
Rarely do products give you the cost per dose, instead relying on the above
“smoke and mirrors” to give you a cheap overall price but requiring you to
reorder twice as much, or they give you the much less effective KCl or the NaCl
forms of glucosamine (only shown when you examine the ingredient list), so that
as much as 30% or more of what you are buying is ordinary table salt, and
more than likely less than effective glucosamine. Do not be fooled by these
tricks! Demand that each product supply you with basic information such as
the dosage, synergistic factors, monthly price and ingredient purity.
The Powerful Benefits of Liquids
Liquids, aside from offering the obvious benefit of being easy to swallow,
have another very important trait. According to the Physicians Desk Reference,
liquid is absorbed at a 98% rate, versus only 10 – 20% in hard capsules or
tablet forms. This very important distinction is extraordinarily important. It
is not uncommon to have capsules pass right through the body in a way that the
product name is still visible after the pill has left the body completely. This
does not happen with liquids, as they are absorbed completely and are not
wasted.
The National Advisory Board states that “100 mg consumed in tablet form
translates to a minute stabilized 8.3 MG or 8.3% concentrated in the blood.”
This is simply not the case with liquids!
Pills and capsules may cost less, but in reality you get far less absorption
for your money. No wonder they cost less! Liquids are fast, you do not even have
to wait for them to dissolve. They start working as soon as you swallow and many
have fairly pleasant flavors. Liquids are especially easy to administer to pets
- simply pour over their food.
Stores like to stock pills because they have a long shelf life (although
liquid glucosamine is stable for years), are easier to handle and can sometimes
cost a little less because they have cheap fillers and binding agents. People
are used to drugs being in pill form, so it makes sense to them. Unfortunately,
things like vitamins and minerals are not lab created artificial chemicals or
drugs that are easily bound with fillers and buffers. No wonder they can be so
hard to absorb! Pills, in some cases do give you some of the active ingredients,
so people buy them, but when it comes to glucosamine, you know better than they
do. Why go to all of the trouble to buy a product that will only give you half
(or less) of the relief you deserve? Let's take a look at some of the leading
brands.
Note on Glucosamine Creams
Glucosamine creams are not reviewed here. There is
absolutely NO evidence that glucosamine can be absorbed through the skin, and
most products that are topical are only going to have glucosamine in them to
help sell the product. They *may* be of some limited targeted use on that one
joint, but for about the same cost you can treat arthritis in your entire body
and even in areas that would be impossible to target such as the spine or
hip.
Conclusion
We suggest products that contain superior purity, high grade glucosamine
sulfate and HCL. Provided the cost is about $30 to $40 a month, if you can find
a quality product that contains more than just glucosamine, it is highly
recommended to try that one first due to the synergistic combined effects of the
ingredients. The most effective products are going to be liquid and have a
multi-pronged approach to easing your arthritis pain and will contain some or
all of the following complementary ingredients:
|
Complementary Ingredients |
|
Chondroitin Sulfate |
|
MSM |
|
Omega 3 Fatty Acids |
|
Manganese Ascorbate |
|
Boswellia (Boswellin) Serrata |
|
Vitamin A |
|
Vitamin C |
|
Vitamin E |
|
Bromelaine |
|
Yucca |
|
Niacinamide |
|
Aloe Vera Gel |
|
|
Glucosamine Side Effects
|
Glucosamine is a dietary supplement that lacks the damaging side
effects and long term toxicity of COX-2 inhibitors or NSAIDS such as
ibuprofen or aspirin. Great, you say. What else do I need to know about
it? Does it have any other side effects that I need to be aware of?
So Just How Safe is Glucosamine?
Glucosamine is overall a very safe substance. It has been studied
clinically since the very early 80’s – so people have been taking it
safely for over 20 years. There are only a few things you need to watch
out for when taking Glucosamine.
Shellfish Allergies Because most Glucosamine is derived from shellfish (a
few manufacturers offer it derived from corn), you should consult your
doctor prior to starting Glucosamine therapy. If the Glucosamine is pure
but derived from shellfish, it is still possible that people who are
allergic to shellfish can take Glucosamine. Because the allergic reaction
is to proteins in shellfish and Glucosamine is derived from Chitin, a
carbohydrate, it is generally ok to try Glucosamine under the guidance of
a doctor because the processing that takes place to extract the
Glucosamine destroys the proteins and the antigens that the body would
normally react to. However, the official recommendation is that if you
have an allergy to shellfish to avoid glucosamine.
Diabetics Insulin levels with Glucosamine (HCL or Sulfate) can
be subject to fluctuations, particularly in diabetics. Glucosamine is
technically a carbohydrate (a sugar), but the body is not able to convert
Glucosamine into Glucose. Hence, Glucosamine does not directly provide
additional sources of Glucose. In diabetic patients, many factors can lead
to changing blood levels and as a result it is very important to check
with your doctor prior to initiating Glucosamine therapy and to be sure to
be very careful about monitoring your blood sugar levels while on
Glucosamine.
Pregnant / Lactating Women Pregnant women should avoid Glucosamine. There have
not been enough long term studies on the fetus to clearly say that
Glucosamine is 100% safe for the developing fetus. There is no evidence
that it would be harmful but it would be best to be safe in a situation
such as this.
Overdose Extremely high
levels of Glucosamine (many times the daily dose) can cause gastric
fluctuations such as soft stools, diarrhea or nausea. Glucosamine does not
have to be taken with meals but it would be convenient to mix with a drink
when you take it if you so desired.
Except for those above advisements, Glucosamine has a long track record
of being very safe, unlike the NSAIDS or COX 2 drugs, which have a long
and very well known (to scientists) history of being toxic you long term.
Notice on the box of aspirin how it states that it is for the temporary
(not ongoing) relief of arthritis pain. Not only are these foreign
substances, (Glucosamine is natural and in your joints right now) even the
later generation COX-2 inhibitors such as Vioxx® or have some rather nasty
potential side effects. Plus, NSAIDS and COX-2 inhibitors do nothing but
cover up the pain. If you stop taking NSAIDS or COX-2 inhibitors, the pain
quickly comes back. Its still there, but your brain is numb to the pain
due to the effects of the drugs. With Glucosamine, there is a residual
effect. Even if you stop taking it, you will still be protected for a
period of time. Although maintaining a daily dose is the best way for
maximum pain relief and joint protection, Glucosamine will be decreasingly
effective for short while after you stop its
administration. |
|
Glucosamine has been shown in clinical study after
clinical study to be effective at relieving joint pain and repairing
cartilage. It is also showing great promise for its ability to slow or
even halt the effects of arthritis. These studies show that Glucosamine is
a safe and effective natural supplement that is better for the body than
NSAIDS such as ibuprofen and aspirin and best of all, glucosamine lacks
the long term detrimental effects so common with NSAIDS. Glucosamine hits
osteoarthritis with a big punch – and keeps it down for the count. But you
already knew that. You just want to figure out how to find the best
glucosamine product out there. Let's go over some important
criteria.
So You Want to Evaluate a Glucosamine
Product?
Not all
glucosamine products are created equal. In order to best evaluate a
product, you need to consider seven things. When your healthcare and pain
relief is at stake, take a moment and consider these criteria: What form
is the glucosamine in? What is the total daily dose? Are there any other
ingredients? What type is the glucosamine? How pure are the ingredients?
What is the total cost? How is the product administered?
The form the glucosamine comes in is critical. There are
three ways to get glucosamine into your system. Oral (e.g. Liquid), direct
IV (into the vein) and intramuscular injection. Unless you really love
daily needles, the oral option is going to be your best bet. Oral methods
provide the best absorption and gives you the maximum dosage as compared
to pills. Your choice of delivery method can mean all of the
difference. If you want maximum absorption, the quickest effects and
the best results, make sure the glucosamine product you are using is a
liquid and not a pill. In addition, be especially aware of any kind of
glucosamine cream based product. They are a waste of money, as there is
no clinical evidence that glucosamine can even be absorbed through
the skin.
The dose size is the next important thing. Almost every
clinical study used a full 1,500 mg of Glucosamine. It is true,
liquid provides the best absorption, but do not sell yourself short with
less than 1,500 mg a day, unless you like getting less than optimal
relief. If you choose a liquid product (as you should) then the dose
should be 1/4 fl oz per day.
Other synergistic ingredients are important. Glucosamine
alone will provide some pain relief, but look for products that contain
other synergistic ingredients that work with the glucosamine to maximize
your relief. While glucosamine is the “heavy hitter” when it comes to
arthritis relief, ensure that you are getting as many “helper” ingredients
as you possibly can, for a reasonable cost. Remember, shark cartilage is
not chondroitin, make sure if you are looking for some additional
chondroitin to make sure the product actually has chondroitin.
Because science has not decided which type is the most
effective (or if there is any difference at all), make sure you are
getting both Glucosamine Sulfate and Glucosamine HCL to maximize your
benefits from the two types. There may even be more benefits from getting
both rather than risking getting the “wrong” type.
Make sure you are getting high quality liquid
glucosamine. Do not settle for anything less. If the manufacturer does not
prominently state the purity of their glucosamine, go elsewhere and fast,
especially if there is no brand name on the glucosamine.
The cost is another important consideration. The best
products are going to be in the $30 to $40 a month range but remember that
is for a FULL 32 days. Be particularly weary of products that claim to be
cheaper than this but DO NOT give you your full month. This is more true
with pills, where you commonly can get 60 pills but need to take 4 a day
to get the “labeled dose” of Glucosamine, which again is not even really
the full amount you would get with a liquid. If you are paying more than
$2 a dose (for a full 1,500 mg of Glucosamine and other synergistic
ingredients), you are paying way too much. Some of the best liquid
products cost about a dollar a day.
The method of administration is important. You already
know why, with glucosamine, pills are not a good option and why liquids
are superior but with some products, liquids can be difficult to
administer |
Thank you for visiting the Glucosamine Research Center. Here
you will be able to find current research on glucosamine, usage information,
clinical abstracts, lay person interpretations, and even a search feature to
effortless find the information you need. Below you will find links to actual
cited peer reviewed clinical studies and an easy to understand interpretation of
every one of the results.
Research into the leading commercial products available today.
Each product is evaluated by type, method of delivery, quality, any additional
ingredients and price.
This
study collected 13 studies and reviewed them to see what Glucosamine's effect
was on arthritis. Glucosamine was found to be much more effective than placebo
and at least equivalent if not superior in the long term than Ibuprofen, without
the deteriorating effects on the body that NSAIDs such as Ibuprofen have been
shown to have on the body such as the digestive tract and other major organs.
Different products vary in how much Glucosamine they contain but the average
amount recommended was 1500 mg Glucosamine. The expected cost should be from
$30-$45 a month for the product.
This clinical abstract (published in 1980! - Glucosamine has
been studied in humans for well over 20 years) suggests that glucosamine should
be considered the basic therapy of choice for primary (develops with age) or
secondary (injury caused) arthrosis.
Glucosamine was found to be effectively able to diffuse into
the body via oral (such as swallowed liquid) forms, IV (needles into veins),
intramuscular (shots into the muscle). All forms allowed the glucosamine to be
dispersed and absorbed into the body effectively and thus all three methods are
effective routes of administration for Glucosamine. It can be safely said that
oral routes (the kind that does not involve needles) are most likely the most
popular method of administration.
Glucosamine was again tested for a period of three years
against placebo in a placebo controlled double blind study, and the results were
astoundingly in favor of Glucosamine. Placebo joint narrowing (How much
"cushion" exists between the bones, more is better) was much more pronounced
over Glucosamine, showing -.29 to .09 mm DETERIORATION with placebo versus a
-.06 to .14 mm GROWTH with Glucosamine. Fewer patients with Glucosamine showed
severe narrowings over placebo and the side effect profiles for both placebo and
Glucosamine were the same.
Glucosamine was shown to be a structure (cartilage) regrowing
drug. In rabbits, the lesions that simulated osteoarthritis were much smaller in
the Glucosamine group and much larger in the group that received nothing (the
control group).
A double blind clinical study that evaluated the effects of
injected(!) Glucosamine verses placebo. Glucosamine reduced pain to a
significantly greater degree than did placebo. The resulting joint flexibility
was much higher with glucosamine therapy. Note: Glucosamine does *NOT* need to
be injected to be effective. The liquid form will provide quick and effective
absorption without daily needle sticks and the possibility of
infections.
Given
the detrimental effects of NSAIDs on joints and other organs, their use should
be discouraged and their classification as a first choice conservative treatment
should be abolished. A more appropriate treatment for arthritis would involve
trying to keep the joints mobile through exercise and diet, and using
glucosamine sulfate to aid in the pain reduction and regeneration of destroyed
joints.
In clinical trials, Glucosamine was more effective than
placebo in controlling the symptoms of osteoarthritis. It was also found to be
more effective than Ibuprofen. In addition, a whopping 35% of Ibuprofen users
reported adverse events (generally stomach related) with their treatment, versus
only 6% of the Glucosamine group. (Remember, hundreds of thousands of people use
Ibuprofen every year.)
The patients report of pain, stiffness, and the mobility,
tenderness and swelling of the joint were measured during the trial. The
patients who received the Glucosamine experienced twice as much (or more) pain
reduction and this occurred twice as fast (or faster).
This was a study that reviewed other studies that have
taken place on Glucosamine, Ibuprofen (a NSAID) and placebo. In every study,
Glucosamine was shown to be always be more effective than placebo and be atleast
as effective (if not more so) than Ibuprofen, which carries risks when it is
used for long periods of time. Overall, Glucosamine has been shown to be an
effective therapeutic nutraceutical for certain kinds and locations of arthritis
with almost no side effects.
Both glucosamine and ibuprofen significantly reduced the
symptoms of osteoarthritis with the trend of Glucosamine to be more effective.
After 2 weeks of drug discontinuation there was a remnant therapeutic effect in
both groups, with the trend to be more pronounced in the Glucosamine group.
Glucosamine was significantly better tolerated than ibuprofen, as shown by the
adverse drug reactions.
The therapeutic effects of Glucosamine with regard to the
anti-inflammatory activities seems comparable or superior to that of the known
non-steroidal anti-inflammatories (NSAIDS) such as ibuprofen, naproxen or
aspirin. Compared to the NSAIDS, Glucosamine's side effects on the stomach and
digestive tract were virtually absent. Glucosamine also lacks the eroditive
effects of long term NSAIDS use.
To order Joint
care supplements, click here
|